best lawn spreader reviews

The Best Lawn Fertilizer Spreader Reviews – Buyer’s Guide

The market holds a large assortment of lawn spreaders. There are some that are great for smaller lawns, and some spreaders that are great for large sized yards. Not only can you use it for grass seeds, but they also typically work for salt for melting ice, lawn fertilizer and feed for animals.

Homeowners want to have a beautiful lawn, and this requires a well-maintained lawn. A lawn that is splotchy and brown isn’t appealing to the eye; it takes away from the curb appeal. One would typically begin the search for a lawn spreader before early spring; the most common time to plant grass seed is in the early to late spring.

A lawn spreader is a valuable tool for any homeowner. It helps you quicken the task of spreading seed and helping to consistently apply the seed throughout the lawn. Let’s take a look at some things you should know about the best lawn spreader for you.

Picture

Product

Our Rating

Price

Best Commercial Weed Eaters

Scotts Turf Builder EdgeGuard Mini Broadcast Spreader

Agri-Fab 45-0463 130-Pound Tow Behind Broadcast Spreader

Scotts Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, (Up to 10,000-sq ft)

Earthway 2150 Commercial 50 Pound Walk-Behind Broadcast Spreader

Agri-Fab 45-0462 Push Broadcast Spreader

Things to Think About Before You Decide

Lawn spreaders are a fairly simple tool. There aren’t a lot of parts. However, it is important to match the right spreader for your scenario. Before you make your selection, think about some of the answers to these questions.

  • How large is the area you are seeding?
  • Does the area have a large amount of trees and shrubs?
  • Is the area going to require precision seeding at any point?
  • Do you have time to devote to spreading grass seed or fertilizer?

Types of Lawn Spreader

​There are two types of lawn spreaders to consider: drop spreaders and broadcast spreaders. You could use a hand crank spreader, but those will cause you tons of frustration and a sore arm. The push lawn spreaders are the most common options, but they will cost a bit more than the hand crank option.

1. Broadcast spreaders

Broadcast spreaders are sometimes referred to as a rotary spreader. If you have a large lawn or acreage, this would be a great option for you. They are able to cover a wide variety of space. However, you aren’t always able to control the spread of the seed since the disc inside doesn’t have a uniform way of spreading.

You will find the area closest to the spreader will get the best fertilization or seed spread. The outer areas won’t be done evenly. This can be a problem for grass seed, as you want an even large without dirt spots. To solve this problem, go over the areas more than once.

  • They can throw out seed as far away as 8 feet.
  • You need to walk at a steady pace to effectively cover your lawn.
  • They require skill to get a uniform coverage, and they are affected by the wind.
  • Broadcast spreaders can throw seeds outside of bounds.

2. Drop spreaders

Drop spreaders are the most common and favorable option for lawn spreaders. You will get a uniform spread of fertilizer or seed because it comes out of the hopper. Make sure to check the width of the dropper. One of the problems with drop spreaders is you may get stripes if you happen to miss an area. You must be diligent and make sure every area is evenly spread.

  • Homeowners like drop spreaders because they do a better job around your trees and shrubs. You will get a better edging around flower beds and patios with this variety as well.
  • These containers typically resemble a bucket and are mounted on two wheels.
  • As mentioned before, drop spreaders are best for smaller spaces. They work best if your lawn is 5,000 square feet or less.
  • Drop spreaders are not affected by the wind.

The next difference in lawn spreaders is how the seed is spread and delivered. The two options are a hank crank or a walk behind, as mentioned above. There are some reasons you may consider both options.

1

A budget friendly option is a handheld crank operated spreaders. These are best if you have a smaller space; it will take a great deal of time to fully cover all the areas. Hand crank spreaders are like broadcast spreaders; they throw out seeds in every direction. There is no rhyme or reason to where the seeds go.

2

If you have a larger space to cover with seed or fertilizer, a walk behind spreader is the best option. If you have tons of acreage, you could use a tow behind your mower spreader.

This is a wise use of time and money; you can effectively cover your lawn. With these lawn spreaders, you have to make sure you have the right measurement so you can evenly spread the seeds.

The Top 5 Lawn Spreader Reviews

1. Earthway 2150 Commercial 50 Pound Walk-Behind Broadcast Spreader

Earthway 2150 Commercial 50-Pound Walk-Behind Broadcast Spreader

via Amazon

Earthway combines some of the features of the other spreaders into one. It is small enough that you can easily push it around your yard without back pain, yet the hopper holds 50lbs of grass seed. This is enough seed for a nice sized yard.

Pros

via Amazon

  • One of the gripes about broadcast spreaders is the uneven spread of seeds. Earthway has 3 different holds that disperse the seeds, giving a more uniform spread of the product across the lawn. On the handle, you can control the rate of distribution. Also, the faster you walk, the faster the seed comes out. You can control the speed with the rate you walk.
  • The spreader isn’t as heavy as some of the other options.
  • The handle is adjustable, so tall and short people can use this spreader with comfort and ease.
  • It is designed for durability and strength.
  • It can hold a lot of weight. If you have to distribute salt or heavier material, there is no worry about whether it can handle the weight.
  • You’ll love this lawn spreader if you have a larger job. You won’t even notice the weight, and it comes with a solid, 3-year warranty.

The Green Works G-Max is a bit pricy for an electric pruner. However, it is very strong and well crafted. It will last you for years to come.

2. Agri-Fab 45-0463 130-Pound Tow Behind Broadcast Spreader

best broadcast spreader

via Amazon

Some people own quite a bit of land and require a larger lawn spreader than the typical drop or broadcast spreader. The Agri-Fab allows you to tow it behind a riding lawn mower, tractor, or even something like an ATV.

Pros

  • You can use this for over 10,000 square feet of lawn. This tow behind broadcast spreader can hold 130 pounds of grass seed. 130 pounds of grass seed can cover around 1 acre of land or around 25,000 square feet.
  • It is made with large and durable wheels; they are 13 inches in diameter and 4 inches wide. The wheelbase is made wider – 27 inches - for additional stability for those harder terrains.
  • You can tow this along rugged, bumpy land, and it will still perform perfectly.
  • One of the nice features of this Agri-Fab is there is an on-off rod that allows you to control the settings from your seat. You don’t have to get on and off of the mower or tractor. You can easily control the flow; not all tow behind lawn spreaders have this option.
  • Although there is some assembly required, it is easy and the directions will make the process go by fast. It comes with a 3-year warranty; if at any time you are unpleased, they have great customer service.
  • Overall, if you have a large job and want a durable lawn spreader, this Agri-Fab is the perfect choice!

3. Scotts Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader, (Up to 10,000-sq ft)

best fertilizer spreader

via Amazon

Scotts is known for making quality outdoor tools. They are durable and quality products. While the last spreader was for a smaller lawn, the Class Drop Spreader is for lawns up to 10,000 square feet. Because it is meant for larger lawns, the frame was created with heavy duty materials; this ensures stability.

Pros

via Amazon

  • The way a drop spreader works is by a dropper under the bottom of the lawn spreader. It is like a chute underneath the tool. The chute is 22 inches wide; this gives great coverage for your yard. You won’t have to do too many rows to cover the space.
  • The hopper is wide, so you can easily fill it with seeds.
  • While it says that it is pre-calibrated, you should make sure to do it again before use to ensure it is correct.
  • Overall, this is a great drop spreader for larger yards. If you have a lot of shrubs or sidewalks to go around, this would be the perfect choice.

4. Scotts Turf Builder EdgeGuard Mini Broadcast Spreader

best drop spreader

via Amazon

If you want a simple, pre-assembled lawn spreader, Scotts has a great option. The mini broadcast spreader is meant for lawns that are 5,000 square feet or less. Scotts is a name that most people can recognize. This company makes a huge amount of products for outdoor lawn care. They also sell their own grass seed blends.

Pros

towbehind lawn spreader

via Amazon

  • It is lightweight and compact; you will have no trouble pushing this spreader around your whole lawn.
  • The wheels are big, so you can roll over rocks and uneven ground easily. Even though the name of this spreader calls it a mini, it still can cover a nice sized lawn.
  • The handle is tall, so you don’t have to watch hunched over.
  • One of the issues with broadcast spreaders is you generally have little control over where the seeds end up. Precision is difficult in these kinds of lawn spreaders. Scotts had a solution for this problem; they created what they call Scotts “EdgeGuard Technology.” This lets the user block off the spreader from spraying out of the sides. If you have to place seeds along your patio or flowerbed, it is an easy adjustment to make and a very nice feature.
  • Scotts made this lawn spreader ready to go. All you have to do is put the bag of seeds into the container, and you’ll be ready to go in no time. It isn’t a large product, so you can easily store the spreader for later use!

5. Agri-Fab 45-0462 Push Broadcast Spreader

Agri-Fab 45-0462 Push Broadcast Spreader

via Amazon

Here is another broadcast spreader made by Agri-Fab. Just like the previous one, this spreader can hold 130lbs of grass seed.

Pros

  • This spreader can hold 130lbs of grass seed.This will cover around 25,000 square feet of lawn.
  • However, unlike the previous Agri-Fab, this one is a push-style spreader. It weighs about 35lbs, so it may take a bit of effort to push. However, the wide and durable tires will make the job so much easier.
  • The spreader throws the seeds 10 to 12 feet in diameter; you will get a great coverage of your lawn.
  • You get great quality with this spreader.
  • It is made with a powder coated metal frame. It is not completely assembled; you will need to put about an hour into assembly.
  • The hopper is wide and allows you to fill it with ease.
  • If you are looking for a broadcast spreader that you can use for a rather large yard, you are going to be pleased with this Agri-Fab. Because of its solid design, you can roll over uneven and bumpy terrain with ease.
  • You will get great coverage, and your job will be done in no time.

Which Lawn Fertilizer Spreader is the Best?

Best Fertilizer Spreader - My Choice

Once you decide which lawn spreader is for you, these 5 spreaders have some great features and are all made for durability. They will undoubtedly last you for years to come. While they are all great, there is one that stands out among the rest. This is the Earthway Commercial Broadcast Spreader.

It stands out and rates as the best for a few reasons. It weighs less than the Agri-Fab push lawn spreader; this matters for larger spaces. No one wants to strain their back. The hopper can hold 50lbs of seed, so you won’t have to continually fill it with seed. It is made with strength and stability; the wheels are wide and can roll over nearly anything. These are some of the reasons why we love this spreader!

Do you have a favorite lawn spreader? Let us know in the comment section.

About the Author Ann Katelyn

I'm Ann, I have dedicated most of my life in gardening. This is a subject I enjoy the most. Since then, I committed to developing my website to be the best guidance when it comes to taking care of flowers and plants. I am trying my best to be well-versed with plants found in desert areas, tropics or Mediterranean. I still need to be knowledgeable about so many kinds of botanical life.

follow me on:

Leave a Comment: