Sumo Gardener

6 Best Tree Stump Grinder Buying Guide for 2024

Taking any tree out of the garden needs to be done properly, and tree stump grinders are the best way to make this job manageable, whether you’re stump grinding commercially, or just need to remove some troublesome roots from your own garden. 

If you plan on having a professional remove a tree in your garden, consider your options for removing the stump when they’re gone with our buying guide for tree stump grinders and reviews on best tree stump grinders to buy for 2024. 


Best Tree Stump Grinder Buying Guide


Our Rating


1. Bear Cat Stump Grinder

Bear Cat Stump Grinder
Best Stump Grinder

2. DK2 Power OPG777 12 in. x 3.5 in. Gas Stump Grinder

DK2 Power OPG777 12 in. x 3.5 in. Gas Stump Grinder
Best Value Stump Grinder

3. 2021 Vermeer SC30TX Stump Cutter

2021 Vermeer Stump Cutter
Premium Choice Stump Grinder

4. Dosko 200 Series Self Propelled Mini Stump Grinder

Dosko 200 Series Mini Stump Grinder

5. Barreto MFG 31 HP Tracked Self Propelled Stump Grinder

Barreto MFG Tracked Commercial Stump Grinder

6. DK2 Power OPG888E 14 x 4 in. Gas Stump Grinder

DK2 Power OPG777 12 in. x 3.5 in. Gas Stump Grinder

Tree Stump Grinder Buying Guide

If a tree is removed badly, the tree will regrow, but even done right, the stump can get in the way of countless future garden projects, and even worse, stop you from planting anything in the gap where the tree was removed

There are plenty of reasons to keep a tree, but removing one for building work, access, or to let light into the house sometimes has to be done. It is quite challenging to remove a tree stump as it has roots deeply embedded into the soil. 

Best Tree Stump Grinder Reviews

There are a variety of tree stump grinder machines available to remove different types of stumps. You cannot just buy or hire any stump grinding machine to remove a stump. You need to know the right kind of machine suitable for your job.  

Before we get to the details or what stump grinders to buy, let us explore the types of stump grinders and things to consider while choosing one for your yard. 

Types of Stump Grinders

There are two basic types of stump grinders – track grinders and wheel grinders. However, there are a variety of configurations between these two categories. There are self-propelled, walk-behind, and tow-behind models.

  • Self-propelled models have a motor that helps them move. 
  • Walk-behind models require a person to push them to move while the motor is used to rotate the grinding blade.
  • Tow-behind models are attached to a standard truck hitch.

The walk-behind models are more suitable for occasional stump removals like in homes or backyards. Some walk behind models also come with the self-propelled option to make the operation more convenient.

Self-propelled and tow-behind models are much more powerful than the walk-behind models and are used for heavy-duty operations like cutting trees in forests or large landscapes.

Some grinders come with remote operation options to add an extra layer of safety while operating these machines. Out of the most common types of stump grinders, some portable models are often called stump planers or removers.

The vertical stump grinders comes with a rotary drill to drill and destroy the main stump and the roots that could continue to grow.

Gasoline vs Diesel Engine Stump Grinders

Another consideration is to choose between machines operated by gasoline and diesel engines. Gas-powered stump grinders usually have less power than diesel machines.

If you have a small operation where you only need to cut a few stumps at a time, a gas stump shredder may be right. However, for a larger job where you need to go through dozens or even hundreds of stumps quickly, a larger, stump grinder powered by diesel may be a better option.

Tree Stump Grinder Buying Checklist

Tree Stump Grinder Buying Guide


Size and Weight of the Machine

Some machines are small and light and made for the removal of small stumps. Other heavy-duty machines are made for grinding large stumps.

As heavy grinders are not suitable for personal use, one should not use them to remove stumps from the home garden.

Most tree stump grinders have a weight between 816 and 2721 kilograms. However, some heavy-duty grinding machines like Carlton’s Hurricane TRX series can have weight up to 5670 kilograms.  

Therefore, it is best to choose a small and manageable tree stump grinder that is easy to carry and transfer to any place. With some care and caution, a gardener can use a small grinding machine to remove an inconvenient root.

Power of the Machine

Most of the machines make use of similar cutting techniques; you can differentiate them in terms of horsepower. 

The power of a machine determines how quickly it can cut or grind a hard stump. For an average thickness of stumps, you can use a low power grinder, but for heavy and thick stumps, you might need a high-power machine.

The horsepower of tree stump grinders ranges from 25 to 90 horsepower, and you can choose a machine depending on the type of wood to be cut or removed.

Number of Teeth

The number of teeth on the cutter wheel determines the speed and time required for grinding the stump. The smallest models have as few as 12 teeth, while the heavy-duty models can have up to 132 teeth.

More teeth mean faster cutting, and machines with fewer teeth take more time to grind a stump. Therefore, it is best to use a small and light grinder but with more teeth. 

Types of Stump Grinders

Cutting Wheel Size of the Machine

The size of the cutting wheel in a stump grinder can be misleading, for which you need to be extremely careful. The largest wheel does not guarantee the deepest cut. Many factors affect how far below grade a machine can cut.

  • Style and design of the safety guard
  • The angle of the machine on its axle
  • The distance of the axle and the point on which the wheel is mounted.

You need to check the cutting depths before renting or buying a stump grinder to determine whether it will provide the required cutting depth.

The below-grade cutting depths can vary between 9 " and 18", depending on the design and model. Most models cut 16 "to 17" below grade, with 9 "and 18" exceptions at every end.

On the other hand, it is also essential to consider the above grade cutting depth. The above-grade cutting depth tells an estimate of the height of a stump that can be crushed above ground level.

The above grade cutting depths are usually between 10" and 24", although most grinders have above grade depths more than 20". If your stump is too high for the machine, you will need to cut it with a chainsaw to bring it to a manageable height.

If you don't have chainsaw on hand and decide to get your own, it can be quite confusing with how many are available on the market. For easier picking, check out our review on the best professional chainsaws for 2024

Type of Stumps

Age will come into play in terms of the stump's hardness. So, if you have a stump that is rotting, it tends to be softer. In that case, the rail grinder or handlebar tree stump grinder can break through.

One consideration in buying the handle-bar option over a tracked tree stump grinder is that the handle will revolve on its wheels so that it cannot reach higher stumps.

If you have a larger tree with a stump that has been cut much taller, you would need the use of a mat tree stump grinder, because it can cut stumps up to 35 inches, because the cutting head is on a separate lance.

Residential applications are, in fact, another reason for the track design in log shredders, because the tracks distribute the weight of the machine, keeping a lower pressure on the ground so you don't have to worry about ruts or to create conversion marks.

Other Features and Technologies to Look For

A man using a tree stump grinder

Safety is essential while using these machines; that is why many of them come with safety features. Some features like automatic stop, LED lighting, remote start, and swing control and operator presence systems on the handlebars are given to enhance safety during operation.

Durability and stability are important too, and this is where robust remote-control systems, reinforced chassis, all-wheel drive, and dual front and rear wheels are required.

Other features may also include hydraulic fill blades on large machines and adjustable handle-bars and self-propelled features.

Tree Stump Grinder Condition and Price

Most manufacturers offer a warranty when buying new stump cutters but there are plenty available on eBay as second-hand models.

Depending on how often you need to use a stump cutter, it might be worth checking second-hand sellers to make sure you’re not paying too much for something you might only use once.

Equipment Affordability 

So, affordability is an important factor; buying a stump grinder can be expensive as the price can range from $200 to $800. Although renting may cost less for hours or days.

If you have a large landscape with a number of trees that you need to remove every year, buying a grinder is the best option. On the other hand, if you want to use it occasionally, renting is beneficial in terms of cost.

With so many variations in types, sizes and abilities of stump grinders, it can be incredibly difficult to make a confident decision when it comes to buying one, whether for personal use, or for commercial use.

We’ve pulled together some of the best stump grinders on the market, whether you’re after a small stump grinder or an industrial tree stump grinder, with our top pick, best value and premium choice stump grinders at the end of the list.

Tree Stump Grinder Reviews

1. Bear Cat Stump Grinder

Bear Cat Stump Grinder will fit into tight spaces to do its work, and can be moved easily between buildings weightlifting in or moving fence posts

The rotational horizontal stump grinder from Bear Cat will make light work of small stumps, but is less efficient than vertical cutters as it grinds rather than cuts.

By far the biggest advantage of this compact small stump grinder though, is that it will fit into tight spaces to do its work, and can be moved easily between buildings weightlifting in or moving fence posts.

Perfect for leftover shrubs or small thicket clearance.


  • Really easy to store, fold away and transport, weighing just under 200lbs

  • It has the smallest blade in our selection at 9”, but a more powerful belt drive, and sturdier drive shaft than most other small stump cutters, which can handle some really tough jobs.


  • Similar to the Dosko, it is more expensive than other small stump grinders

2. DK2 Power OPG777 12 in. x 3.5 in. 14 HP Gas Stump Grinder

DK2 Power OPG777 12 in. x 3.5 in. 14 HP Gas Stump Grinder

Ok, so the DK2 12-inch stump grinder is a budget option of the DK2 14 inch, but it’s capable of grinding down stumps underground to 9 inches, which is more than enough to plant new shrubs, or bury foundations for lightweight structures.

Considering the capabilities of this small stump grinder in comparison to the very similar Dosco, its price is jaw droppingly low.

DK2 Power OPG777 12 in. x 3.5 in. 14 HP Gas Stump Grinder is capable of grinding down stumps underground to 9 inches


  • A great price for a brilliant manufacturer, and a reliable seller
  • 12-inch blades will do almost all garden and landscape jobs.
  • Easy to store, and transport.
  • Lightweight and foldable.


  • Much smaller than the next size up in the same model, but makes up for it on price.

3. 2021 Vermeer SC30TX Stump Cutter

2021 Vermeer SC30TX Stump Cutter

Vermeer’s SC30TX is a user-friendly stump cutter, with tons of safety features included as standard. It can cut underground down to a depth of 12 inches, but it is the 25 inch over ground cutting that makes this stand out from all other small stump cutters.

When buying from Vermeer you’re getting a guarantee of quality, knowing that they supply reliable products which they constantly review and improve.

2021 Vermeer SC30TX Stump Cutter is a user-friendly stump cutter


  • Incredible power to exert the maximum grind pressure on your unsuspecting tree stumps.
  • 12 inch cutting below ground, and 25 inch cutting over ground makes it the most versatile cutter in our list, capable of tackling the biggest roots.


  • Only for sale to commercial buyers, and require some training

4. Dosko 200 Series Self Propelled Mini Stump Grinder

Dosko 200 Series Self Propelled Mini Stump Grinder

Dosko’s mini stump grinder is perfect for most contractors, or an extravagant purchase for a homeowner who is just desperate to get rid of a troublesome stump.


The reliable vertical cutting blades can handle large stumps, but the small stump cutter will take longer than the larger models to get through them. 

It’s lightweight and will pack onto the back of a truck, or the corner of a garage easily.

Dosko 200 Series Self Propelled Mini Stump Grinder is perfect for most contractors


  • Simple to store, and easily portable
  • Folding handle bar for easy storage


  • No tow bar
  • It’s 10 Inch blade is enough to tackle the radius of most tree stumps, but will struggle of larger stumps
  • Expensive for a small stump cutter

5. Barreto MFG 31 HP Tracked Self Propelled Stump Grinder

Barreto MFG 31 HP Tracked Commercial Stump Grinder

The Barreto 31 horsepower Tracked Stump Grinder will tackle pretty much any stump. It is a beast, and suitable for any commercial tree surgeon and landscaper.

Obviously for domestic use, it is completely inappropriate, but this heavyweight stump cutter is a sturdy, and remarkably safe tool, with tried and tested track drive technology developed for other products by Bear Cat, and a hydraulic drive to the cutting wheel which saves on the cost of replacement belts in years to come.

Barreto MFG 31 HP Tracked Self Propelled Stump Grinder is suitable for any commercial tree surgeon and landscaper


  • 31 horsepower
  • 16” blade will make light work of most stumps


  • Expensive

6. DK2 Power OPG888E 14 x 4 in. 14 HP Electric Start Gas Stump Grinder

DK2 Power OPG888E 14 x 4 in. 14 HP Electric Start Gas Stump Grinder

For the price, the DK2 14-inch stump grinder is a great option for anyone in need of a quick fix. It is completely capable of demolishing stumps up to 10 inches below ground, and 14 inches above ground. 

So, if your tree surgeon has done a good job removing the tree’s top growth, you won’t need to reduce the stump any further before grinding.

DK2 Power OPG888E 14 x 4 in. 14 HP Electric Start Gas Stump Grinder is completely capable of demolishing stumps up to 10 inches below ground, and 14 inches above ground


  • Electric starting makes this a breeze to use, whether you’re a first timer, or a seasoned pro
  • 14” cutting blade makes it the most versatile stump cutter in this price range
  • Surprisingly cheap for a tree stump grinder of this size and power


  • Safety precautions need to be followed to the letter, as the blade is partially exposed with no shielding.

Sumo Gardener's Stump Grinder Top Picks for 2024

Best Stump Grinder - Top Rated

Best Stump Grinder
Bear Cat Stump Grinder

The Bear Cat Stump Grinder might be more expensive than similar models, but its compact size makes it perfect for landscapers in need of a small tool ready to take into new spaces where access might be an issue.

It’s still capable of most jobs, but more importantly, you can get to those jobs without needing a crane!

Best Value Stump Grinder

Best Value Stump Grinder
DK2 Power OPG777 12 in. x 3.5 in. 14 HP Gas Stump Grinder

The DK2 12-inch stump grinder is a really impressive model, and outranks every other small stump grinder on value. It’s cheaper than most others with the same power, and has a better cutting depth underground than some with larger blades, and bigger engines.

It might be the budget option, but it would give the best buy and the premium choice a decent run for their money on small stumps.

Premium Choice Stump Grinder

Premium Choice Stump Grinder
2021 Vermeer SC30TX Stump Cutter

Vermeer’s SC30TX Stump Cutter is by far the most impressive stump cutter we can find on the market. It’s build-quality is unbeatable, and its tracks make it incredibly sturdy and safe to use.

Its only downfall is that you can’t just go out and buy one, as they are supplied to commercial stump cutters direct from Vermeer.

Hiring a Specialist Tree Stump Grinder

Grinders are also available with various specialties like tree loppers Castle Hill who are specialized in pruning and removal of trees. Likewise, they have some other accessories for tree extraction, cutting, and usually multiple stump grinders, depending on the size of the stumps.

Professional Advice

Ask professional landscapers and arborists for better plans and advice, as they are experts in this field so that they can suggest the best, but essential, aspects when purchasing a robust grinder.

Find the best landscaping services in your city. Henshaw Tree Service offers tree removal, and stump removal services in Blacktown and its surroundings.

The company has been offering high-quality landscaping services for years and has thousands of satisfied customers. If you live in Blacktown or nearby areas, you can hire them for tree removal, tree pruning, and other landscaping services.

Visit their website to know more about their services.   

Wrapping Up Tree Stump Grinder Product Reviews and Buying Guide

Whatever you decide to do, remember to take safety seriously when dealing with tree stumps. It’s always tempting to try and cut away at stumps with a chainsaw, but the chain catching iron stones underground can be incredibly dangerous.

Using built for purpose stump grinders is the safest way to remove stumps, and will tackle stumps and roots that chainsaws just can’t budge.

I hope our buying guide, and best buys are useful, but if you don’t find the exact model you’re looking for, don’t forget to refer back to our buying guide so you know what to look out for when buying any tree stump grinder.

About the Author Pat Moreno

Pat is our gardening tool expert here at Sumo Gardener. Working for many years as a private and commercial landscaper, Pat has used almost every type of gardening tool there is. Along with a vast knowledge for types of plants and putting together an amazing looking and maintainable garden, Pat developed a passion for gardening tools as he found that using the right tools vastly improved the ease and outcome of any landscaping job he undertook. When spending hours, days or years using a particular tool, you want to make sure you’ve got the best one for the job, and Pat is the right guy to guide us to the best gardening tools.

Leave a Comment: